Orientalism

De: Edward Said

Narrado por: Peter Ganim

Duración: 19 h y 2 m

Resumen del Editor

This landmark book, first published in 1978, remains one of the most influential books in the Social Sciences, particularly Ethnic Studies and Postcolonialism. Said is best known for describing and critiquing "Orientalism", which he perceived as a constellation of false assumptions underlying Western attitudes toward the East. In Orientalism Said claimed a "subtle and persistent Eurocentric prejudice against Arabo-Islamic peoples and their culture." He argued that a long tradition of false and romanticized images of Asia and the Middle East in Western culture had served as an implicit justification for Europe and the US' colonial and imperial ambitions. Just as fiercely, he denounced the practice of Arab elites who internalized the US and British orientalists' ideas of Arabic culture. Peter Ganim's narration gives the work an elegant and knowledgable voice.

©1978 Edward Said (P)2010 Audible, Inc.

THE work on Orientalism

Will argued with diamond-solid citations and centuries of examples. The quintessential place to start in decolonising your understanding of history.

Timeless classic

Very much worth reading to give important context to the events of today The history has been told through biased Western lens.

We're lucky to have this on audio

In the academic world, this book has become well-known and influential that a realistic estimate of its impact has the sound of hyperbole. That makes it worth reading in the same way as Plato's _Republic_ or Machiavelli's _The Prince_; you may not agree with all or even much of its arguments, but there's much value simply in knowing what these ideas are that so many people are thinking and talking about.

For those who don't know the book, it describes the connections between how European empires (and the US, somewhat) controlled the Middle East politically, fantasized about it, and studied it, arguing that these were all aspects of the same structures and processes. It suffers from a certain amount of contradiction and one-sided argument, but I think that when Said was writing in the 1970s the other side of the argument--the pro-colonialist side--was more frequently heard than it is now.

Another reviewer complained that he quit after listening for 45 minutes and finding that it was all generic political arguments. I think that reviewer never got past the new preface, which does go on for something like 45 minutes. The preface was added around 2004 and is mainly a fairly standard critique of the US invasion of Iraq from the perspective of its early years. There's no solution but to be patient and wait for the book itself to begin.

I've had a print copy for years and never got around to reading it, but am finding the audio version pleasant going. Said's writing is much clearer and jargon-free than many of his admirers--he is a scholar of literature, after all. The reader does well enough to keep my attention, and handles fairly well the French words that show up regularly. There are times when he sounds exactly like a computer-generated voice reading text, but his reading doesn't put me to sleep.

Abstruse.

I guess an earlier reviewer, David Newcastle, Australia, has a couple or so critics here. He titled his review: "Tautological and terribly tedious..." Because of the importance of this book, I am approximately 2/3 the way through Professor Edward Said's seminal work; forcing myself to listen on. Little doubt there is validity to the professor's charge, European Orientalists (many) were motivated by racial supremacism and intolerance of oriental or asiatic peoples from which I originate. I am hoping to read the late professor's take on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Actually it is Israel's conflict with the greater Muslim world which does not recognize the need for a sovereign Jewish state in Dar al-Islam - the territory of Islam. I remember the media accounts of Professor Said in southern Lebanon joining protesters by throwing a stone at Israeli soldiers just across the border. Said and President Obama were acquaintances or friends. There are pictures of the two families dining together. If you like recondite. If you like abstruse scholarship, you will love this book!

Very insightful

Very insightful book. It sheds alot of light on the dynamic between people from the orient and people from the occident, and on the perception and understanding of the oriental by the occidental and by the orientels themselves thanks to centuries of “orientalism”

Narrator

Best narrator ever. His French Arabic and German were perfect. Unless someone else was doing it.

Jin Lee

It was a very difficult book to finish since it covers a vast amounts of history of literature and having small knowledge of it made even harder for me. But, having this audio book helped me finish it.

Critically important reading for all

Said puts into words a phenomenon that plagues scholarship on the “orient” throughout history and up to this day in such a way that puts it into very fascinating perspective.

Will this Work Stand the Test of Time?

I had a History professor who was a fan of Michele Faucault. We also read Said. This edition has a new afterword. I appreciate that Mr. Said has issues with the West. However, in the years in between reading the earlier edition for the first time in the 1990s, and this edition in 2008 and now years after the fizzled hopes of the so-called Arab Spring, I have become convinced that this work is a decidedly Cold War Era project with its indictments of 18th-20th century European colonialism and I am not convinced of its long term usefulness in the face of non-state actors seeking to subjugate the formerly colonized.

TOTALLY AMAZING

This book has been on my “to read/listen” list for some time.
After studying the history of many parts of the world, I found myself ready to tackle this book.
The start, the introduction, lasting about 1.5 hrs. is very interesting, it made me, immediately, wanting to dive into the book further.
This approach is unlike any other book about history I have ever read.
I am of mixed blood and partly grew up in a country which formerly was a colony of The Netherlands.
I have often been discriminated against in the Netherlands.
I always understood the reasons why, but mr. Said explains the facts in a clear and straightforward manner.
The many authors he refers to can be found on Wikipedia, for further study.
I just started his follow up book “Culture and Imperialism”.
I highly recommend reading this book.
It is a great loss that the author, mr. Edward Said died, at a relatively young age.
The narrator, mr. Peter Ganim did an excellent job.
Thank you, Audible, we need more of these kind of books, JK.